The Endless Myth and the Jerry Cotton Series Compared: Endless Stories of Myth and Mass-Produced Heroes
At first glance, the novel The Endless Myth and the long-running German crime fiction series Jerry Cotton seem to belong to entirely different genres. The former is a philosophical fantasy centered on myth and faith, while the latter is a mass-produced hardboiled series featuring an FBI agent as its protagonist. Yet both share a crucial common trait: they are built on narrative structures that are not meant to end. This article compares The Endless Myth and the Jerry Cotton series, focusing on why their stories continue indefinitely and how they portray human agency.
Genre and Worldview
The Endless Myth depicts a closed world in which faith and mythology form the basis of social order. Myth functions not only as story but as institution, binding people to meaning and shaping how they live.
By contrast, the Jerry Cotton series is set in contemporary America and follows criminal investigations grounded in realism. Law and order serve as the foundation of the world, and there are no mythological elements. Each story revolves around the cycle of crime and resolution.
Why the Stories Never End
In The Endless Myth, the story cannot end because people continue to need myth. Myths are constantly revised, retold, and preserved. Allowing the story to end would mean the collapse of meaning itself.
The Jerry Cotton series continues for far more practical reasons. Crimes never stop occurring, and the protagonist continues to solve them as part of his professional role. The series is sustained not by narrative continuity, but by repetition.
Protagonists Compared: Symbol vs. Function
The protagonist of The Endless Myth, the Messiah, is consumed as a symbol. His personal emotions and choices are overwritten by the role imposed on him by myth.
Jerry Cotton, on the other hand, is depicted as an almost unchanging character. He shows little growth or transformation and exists primarily to fulfill a function: solving cases as an FBI agent.
The Messiah: a bearer of imposed meaning
Jerry Cotton: a performer of assigned duties
This contrast reveals a fundamental difference in narrative purpose.
Humanity’s Position in the World
In The Endless Myth, humans appear to shape the world, yet in reality they are trapped within mythological structures. Free will exists only in limited form.
In the Jerry Cotton series, humans are problem solvers. Although the world is thrown into disorder by crime, order is ultimately restored through human judgment and action. This reflects a clear form of humanism.
Presence or Absence of Ideology
The Endless Myth centers on philosophical questions such as:
What is faith?
Why do humans need stories?
How does meaning come to restrain human freedom?
The Jerry Cotton series does not foreground ideology. Instead, it consistently presents moral clarity and professional ethics. Readers are not asked to reflect deeply, but to feel reassurance in the restoration of order.
Conclusion: Opposite Reasons for Endless Stories
The Endless Myth and the Jerry Cotton series represent two opposing models of narrative continuity:
A story that cannot end because it cannot abandon meaning
A story that does not end because it continues to perform its function
One binds people through myth, while the other keeps the world turning through roles and routines. Though both are “endless,” their internal logic is fundamentally different. This contrast highlights the diverse ways stories function within society.
The World That Was Never the Same - Endless Myth version1
0 件のコメント:
コメントを投稿